Compare a visible annual renewal with prepaid discounts, withdrawal costs and DNS or mail dependencies.
THE ATN TAKE · EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT
Gandi publishes a US$38.38 standard one-year .com renewal. NameSilo publishes standard and Account Funds registration prices, but its exact current renewal and transfer quotes remain unresolved. Evaluate the prepaid cash commitment and service dependencies before treating a discounted first year as a lower long-term bill. [1][3][5][23]
GandiDomain registration with LiveDNS and DNSSEC listed among included services; separate hosting and email products need their own review. [1][2]
NameSiloDomain registration; hosting and email require separate service checks. [3][4]
.com · first year
GandiUS$11.00 for one standard non-premium .com year in the U.S. view, before applicable tax. [1]
NameSiloUS$17.29 standard .com registration in the 1–49 order tier, or US$11.05 at the entry Account Funds discount tier. Discount top-ups must be at least US$50; ICANN is included, location taxes can apply. [3][5][6][7]
.com · one-year renewal
GandiUS$38.38 for a standard one-year renewal. US$34.54/year promotional renewal requires a 2–9-year term; tax and checkout conditions apply. [1]
NameSiloExact current one-year .com renewal quote remains unverified. Eligible renewals participate in the funded discount program, but a registration price is not a verified renewal quote. [3][5][8]
DNS and nameserver choice
GandiLiveDNS or external nameservers. Switching away deactivates optional Premium DNS; prepare existing website and email records first. [9]
NameSiloExternal nameservers allowed; supported TLDs have DS/DNSSEC controls. Incorrect DS coordination can stop resolution. NameSilo-hosted DNS terminates on transfer-out. [10][11][4]
Registration-data privacy
GandiFree default redaction with extension exceptions. State, country, anonymized email and applicable company name may remain visible; the registrar retains underlying data. [12][2]
NameSiloFree PrivacyGuardian substitution on eligible extensions, with TLD exceptions. Verify the actual privacy toggle: public documents differ on defaults. Provider-held data and lawful disclosure remain outside public masking. [13][14][7][4][15]
Transfer and exit conditions
GandiUS$11.00 listed for .com transfer-in, generally adding a year. Transfer-out uses unlock/auth code and registry rules. Review associated mail dependencies and export needed mail before leaving. [1][16][17]
NameSiloExact current .com transfer-in price unverified. Transfer-out needs unlock, EPP and eligibility; no registration/transfer in the preceding 60 days. Arrange replacement DNS before leaving if using NameSilo DNS. [3][18][4][19]
Renewal and refund rules
GandiOptional auto-renew can begin about a month before the applicable cutoff and follows the prior manual term. Once launched, Gandi says it cannot be cancelled/refunded; registry rules limit other refunds. [20][2]
NameSiloOptional auto-renew runs at the start of the expiry month. Three-day renewal refunds generally require deleting the domain and losing its remaining term; Account Funds withdrawal has separate waiting periods and fees. [21][22][4][23]
Registrar-use conditions
GandiDomain-specific and general terms require accurate registrant information and lawful, rights-respecting use. Registration does not establish case-specific adult-business or hosting approval. [24][2][17]
NameSiloRegistrar terms require lawful, rights-respecting domain use and permit suspension for abuse. These terms do not confirm hosting or adult-business approval. [4]
Affiliate status
GandiCustomer referrals generally reward a US$5 discount code after a qualifying friend’s first order of at least US$3; the third reward differs. This is not a verified cash-affiliate program or ATN tracking link. [25]
NameSilo10% on qualifying first registration/transfer orders from new customers. One-year attribution uses the latest affiliate link, with affiliate-coupon overrides and exclusions. ATN acceptance is unverified. [26][27]
Decision pointATN assessment
GandiIncluded DNS services that justify the recurring bill for the actual domain; compare the same renewal term and check attached mail before transferring away. [1][9][16]
NameSiloA planned domain budget that can use prepaid funds and external DNS. Compare the standard route, withdrawal conditions and missing renewal/transfer quotes before committing. [5][23][10][3]
Standard non-premium .com registration for non-graphic business and editorial sites. Prices are dated provider snapshots; currency, taxes, renewal term and promotional conditions remain explicit. Domain registration, DNS, hosting and affiliate admission are separate decisions. No support, reliability, security or recovery outcomes were independently tested.
NameSilo’s US$50 top-up is prepaid balance rather than a membership fee. Its funding terms permit only full-balance withdrawal after more than 60 days since the last top-up, with 3.4–4% transaction refund fees and no cryptocurrency refund. Budget for the funds you will actually use. [5][23]
Keep the missing renewal amount visible
Gandi’s U.S. table distinguishes its regular one-year renewal from the 2–9-year promotion. NameSilo confirms eligible renewals can use its discount program, but the retrieved table establishes registration prices only. The US$11.05 entry discount cannot be reused as a verified renewal quote. [1][3][5][8]
Plan the service that must continue after transfer
Both permit external nameservers. NameSilo’s agreement ends its hosted DNS after transfer-out, so replacement DNS must be ready. Gandi separately warns about associated GandiMail shutdown and later deletion; applicability to a current paid mail contract needs checking. Domain transfer alone is not a tested continuity plan. [10][4][9][16]
Check the renewal schedule and consequences
NameSilo’s optional auto-renew runs at the start of the expiry month. Its short renewal-refund route generally deletes the domain and remaining term, with certain auto-renew exceptions. Gandi’s optional early renewal follows its own cutoff and cannot be cancelled once launched. Disable future billing before the applicable attempt. [21][22][4][20]
Inspect the actual privacy setting
Gandi describes default redaction with fields that can remain public. NameSilo’s policy and cart guide disagree on privacy defaults, so an included PrivacyGuardian feature is insufficient evidence that the desired setting is active. Neither public masking removes provider-held registrant records or legal disclosure obligations. [12][2][13][14][7][4]
Separate cash commissions from customer coupons
Gandi’s qualified customer referrals generally earn discount codes, with a different third reward. NameSilo’s affiliate commission covers qualifying new-customer first registration/transfer orders, with attribution and exclusions. Neither establishes ATN acceptance or an exact renewal price, and registrar terms do not confirm hosting approval. [25][2][26][27][4]
Research based · No hands-on testing or numeric scores · Direct links, no affiliate tracking. Our editorial standards