Two ongoing free cross-device vaults, with different alias, sharing and paid-feature boundaries.
THE ATN TAKE · EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT
Start by checking whether either Free plan already meets your device and sharing needs. Proton includes a limited number of email aliases and shared vaults; Bitwarden separates individual accounts from its small free organization. Compare paid features and recovery arrangements before paying. Neither provider’s encryption description establishes a tested privacy or security winner. [3][4][2]
Proton PassAn account-based vault for passwords and passkeys; Proton documents end-to-end encryption of vault contents. [1]
BitwardenA standalone password vault with apps and browser extensions. [2]
Starting option
Proton PassFree: unlimited logins and devices, ten email aliases, two vaults and vault sharing with two others; no card required. [3]
BitwardenOngoing Free plan with unlimited passwords and devices. [4]
Paid upgrade
Proton PassYearly Pass Plus is displayed at $35.88 per 12 months ($2.99/month equivalent). Renewal uses then-current pricing; confirm currency and tax. The initial 30-day refund requires cancellation and a request, with payment-method and reseller exceptions. [3][5]
BitwardenPremium for one person: US$19.80/year before tax, billed annually and renewed automatically. US$1.65/month is the annual-plan equivalent. After expiry the account returns to Free; download paid attachments beforehand. [2][6][7]
Phone workflow
Proton PassAndroid and iOS apps; the documented export workflow requires a supported extension, web app or Windows app. [3][8]
Proton PassAutomatic account sync across supported desktop, mobile, web and browser apps. Free includes limited shared vaults; individual-item links and expanded sharing are paid features. [3]
BitwardenCross-device vault synchronization is included on Free. A separate free organization supports two people and two collections; individual Premium alone is not a shared organization. [4]
What to consider
Proton PassPrepare encrypted-data recovery before a reset. Alias addresses remain readable for forwarding even though vault contents are encrypted. Supported non-mobile clients offer encrypted JSON ZIP or readable ZIP/CSV export; transfer fidelity was not tested. [9][10][8]
BitwardenBitwarden cannot retrieve or reset a forgotten master password. Arrange a recovery method and a usable backup before losing access. Password-protected encrypted exports can move to another Bitwarden account; account-restricted exports cannot. Vault encryption does not eliminate account or usage metadata. [11][12][13]
Consider it forATN assessment
Proton PassIndividuals wanting a separate cross-platform vault with email aliases and limited free sharing. Its affiliate program prohibits promotion on adult sites; no ATN participation or tracking link is established. This is a publisher restriction, not a customer-use finding. [3][14][15]
BitwardenA free personal vault across different devices, with optional paid recovery and authenticator features. The official creator-collaboration invitation does not establish public cash affiliate terms or ATN approval. [2][4][16]
Personal password-manager workflows; original KeePass 2.x only. Provider documentation is separate from editorial fit. We have not tested autofill, recovery, exports or resistance to compromise, or assessed independent audit reports. Family and business plans have separate terms.
Proton Free lists two vaults and sharing with two other people; individual-item links and expanded sharing are paid features. Bitwarden’s free organization supports two users and two collections. Premium for one person is not a larger organization plan. These limits are not equivalent team-seat offers. [3][4]
Use a complete annual quote
Bitwarden lists Premium at US$19.80 annually before tax. Proton’s yearly Plus card displays $35.88 per 12 months, but the retrieved page does not identify the ISO currency. Confirm currency, taxes and the renewal rate before comparing totals. Neither monthly equivalent is evidence of a month-to-month commitment. [2][6][3][5]
Recover encrypted data as well as access
Proton’s prepared recovery phrase can restore account access and encrypted data; an email or SMS password reset alone may not unlock the old vault. Bitwarden cannot retrieve a forgotten master password. Its two encrypted-export options have different account restrictions. Practice the chosen backup and recovery approach before losing access. [9][11][12][8]
Keep vault privacy distinct from surrounding data
Proton says vault contents are encrypted while alias addresses remain readable for forwarding. Bitwarden’s policy covers administrative, usage and payment data separately from encrypted vaults. Proton prohibits affiliate promotion on adult sites; Bitwarden’s public collaboration page does not establish cash commission terms. Those publisher findings do not determine product security or customer eligibility. [10][13][14][16]
Research based · No hands-on testing or numeric scores · Direct links, no affiliate tracking. Our editorial standards