A synchronized account vault with a free tier versus a password database file you maintain.
THE ATN TAKE · EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT
Proton Pass packages cross-device account access, aliases and limited sharing into an ongoing Free plan. Original KeePass 2.x gives you a database file with no license fee and leaves file storage, synchronization and phone-app selection to you. Compare the maintenance and recovery routine you can reliably support. This article does not assess KeePassXC or apply original KeePass’s claims to third-party ports. [4][5][3][7]
Proton PassAn account-based vault for passwords and passkeys; Proton documents end-to-end encryption of vault contents. [1]
KeePassA password database file you manage; this entry covers original KeePass 2.x. [2][3]
Starting option
Proton PassFree: unlimited logins and devices, ten email aliases, two vaults and vault sharing with two others; no card required. [4]
KeePassFree software, including company use; no licence fee. [5]
Paid upgrade
Proton PassYearly Pass Plus is displayed at $35.88 per 12 months ($2.99/month equivalent). Renewal uses then-current pricing; confirm currency and tax. The initial 30-day refund requires cancellation and a request, with payment-method and reseller exceptions. [4][6]
KeePassNo original-app subscription or renewal. Separate ports and storage services need separate cost checks. [5][7]
Phone workflow
Proton PassAndroid and iOS apps; the documented export workflow requires a supported extension, web app or Windows app. [4][8]
KeePassAndroid and iOS options are separate contributed or unofficial ports, with their own maintainers and terms. [7]
Across devices
Proton PassAutomatic account sync across supported desktop, mobile, web and browser apps. Free includes limited shared vaults; individual-item links and expanded sharing are paid features. [4]
KeePassKeePass 2.x merges database copies; you arrange file storage, access and synchronization. [3]
What to consider
Proton PassPrepare encrypted-data recovery before a reset. Alias addresses remain readable for forwarding even though vault contents are encrypted. Supported non-mobile clients offer encrypted JSON ZIP or readable ZIP/CSV export; transfer fidelity was not tested. [9][10][8]
KeePassEvery configured master-key component is required; there is no universal recovery key. Shared databases lack per-entry permissions. Protect readable exports and check target-format support. Encryption does not protect a compromised endpoint; storage-provider and phone-port privacy need separate assessment. [2][11][12][13][14]
Consider it forATN assessment
Proton PassIndividuals wanting a separate cross-platform vault with email aliases and limited free sharing. Its affiliate program prohibits promotion on adult sites; no ATN participation or tracking link is established. This is a publisher restriction, not a customer-use finding. [4][15][16]
KeePassPeople comfortable managing a password file, independent backups and any separate phone app. The official project lists community support and donations; a commission program was not found in the checked material. [2][7][5]
Personal password-manager workflows; original KeePass 2.x only. Provider documentation is separate from editorial fit. We have not tested autofill, recovery, exports or resistance to compromise, or assessed independent audit reports. Family and business plans have separate terms.
Proton Free lists unlimited logins and devices, ten aliases and limited shared vaults; paid plans expand those features. Original KeePass has no recurring application fee, including company use. Chosen phone ports and external storage have separate costs and terms. Neither an application’s price nor a free tier establishes the cost of every surrounding service. [4][5][7]
Decide who should access what
Proton Free supports sharing its limited vaults with two others. KeePass database users share the required master credentials, with no per-entry permission model. File access and write permissions are separate from item-level access. Match the actual sharing scope to the people authorized to receive credentials. [4][11]
Preserve every recovery dependency
A prepared Proton recovery phrase can restore account access and encrypted data; email or SMS reset alone may leave older encrypted data inaccessible. KeePass needs every configured master-key component. A database copy without its required key material is not a usable recovery plan. Keep backups and recovery material independently accessible. [9][2]
Compare where data leaves your control
Proton describes encrypted vault contents but retains readable alias addresses for forwarding. KeePass’s database encryption does not cover every third-party port, storage provider or compromised device. Both workflows require a separate assessment of exports and backups. No encryption implementation, independent audit or transfer fidelity was tested. [10][8][13][14][12]
Research based · No hands-on testing or numeric scores · Direct links, no affiliate tracking. Our editorial standards