A separate vault with aliases versus credentials integrated with a Google and Chrome account workflow.
THE ATN TAKE · EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT
Google Password Manager may suit an established Chrome or Android routine without a separate subscription. Proton Pass offers a distinct cross-platform vault with limited free aliases and sharing. Decide where your account dependencies, recipients and recovery material should sit. The comparison does not assume that Google’s optional encryption configuration is enabled or that either service collects no metadata. [4][7][3][9]
Proton PassAn account-based vault for passwords and passkeys; Proton documents end-to-end encryption of vault contents. [1]
Google Password ManagerPasswords and passkeys within the Google, Chrome and Android workflow. [2]
Starting option
Proton PassFree: unlimited logins and devices, ten email aliases, two vaults and vault sharing with two others; no card required. [3]
Google Password ManagerIncluded in the documented Google / Chrome workflow; no separate price listed. [4]
Paid upgrade
Proton PassYearly Pass Plus is displayed at $35.88 per 12 months ($2.99/month equivalent). Renewal uses then-current pricing; confirm currency and tax. The initial 30-day refund requires cancellation and a request, with payment-method and reseller exceptions. [3][5]
Google Password ManagerNo separate Password Manager upgrade or renewal price is listed. [4]
Phone workflow
Proton PassAndroid and iOS apps; the documented export workflow requires a supported extension, web app or Windows app. [3][6]
Google Password ManagerAndroid autofill; on iOS, configure Chrome in AutoFill settings. [4]
Across devices
Proton PassAutomatic account sync across supported desktop, mobile, web and browser apps. Free includes limited shared vaults; individual-item links and expanded sharing are paid features. [3]
Google Password ManagerAccount-saved credentials follow your Google account; signed-out Chrome passwords remain on that device. Family sharing sends a password copy to a member of your Google family group; this is not a team permission system. [7]
What to consider
Proton PassPrepare encrypted-data recovery before a reset. Alias addresses remain readable for forwarding even though vault contents are encrypted. Supported non-mobile clients offer encrypted JSON ZIP or readable ZIP/CSV export; transfer fidelity was not tested. [8][9][6]
Google Password ManagerCheck on-device encryption and account/device recovery. Password sharing is limited to your Google family group. The product records usage and diagnostics. Documented CSV export covers passwords; passkey migration was not established. [10][7][2][11][12]
Consider it forATN assessment
Proton PassIndividuals wanting a separate cross-platform vault with email aliases and limited free sharing. Its affiliate program prohibits promotion on adult sites; no ATN participation or tracking link is established. This is a publisher restriction, not a customer-use finding. [3][13][14]
Google Password ManagerPeople already using Chrome and Android who want account-integrated password management. [4]
Personal password-manager workflows; original KeePass 2.x only. Provider documentation is separate from editorial fit. We have not tested autofill, recovery, exports or resistance to compromise, or assessed independent audit reports. Family and business plans have separate terms.
Google distinguishes passwords saved to the account from signed-out Chrome passwords retained on one device. Proton documents account sync across supported apps. On iOS, Google’s workflow uses Chrome in AutoFill settings. Check the exact device setup instead of assuming every credential is synchronized. [7][4][3]
Check who can receive a credential
Google password sharing is restricted to members of your Google family group and copies the credential into their account. Proton Free lists vault sharing with two others; paid plans expand that scope and add individual-item links. Neither personal offer is a substitute for an organization permission and offboarding plan. [7][3]
Review encryption and recovery settings
Google documents standard and on-device encryption separately; losing all recovery options and signed-in devices can cause password loss. Proton distinguishes resetting account access from recovering previously encrypted data. Configure recovery before a migration and keep recovery material outside the account it restores. [10][12][8]
Do not equate export with complete portability
Google’s checked detailed export guidance describes password CSV; it does not establish a complete passkey migration. Proton offers encrypted JSON ZIP and readable exports on supported non-mobile clients. Test target-format support and protect readable files. Neither migration fidelity nor iOS feature parity was tested for this article. [11][6]
Research based · No hands-on testing or numeric scores · Direct links, no affiliate tracking. Our editorial standards